I am beyond being embarrassed. I was hesitant to ask for help because to me I would feel like a failure. However in light of yesterday and today's recent events I am officially beyond embarrassed. I have a problem...well, let me rephrase that...I have a child who has a problem. Therefore, I have a problem. We are having what I am calling "poop regression." She has been very nicely pooping and peeing in the toliet for quite some time now. We are going on I believe week three...the week before Easter, the week after Easter, and this week...of poop regression. Her bowel system is on a great schedule...I can count on her pooping everyday between 1 and 2 in the afternoon. Unfortunately, that is right at the beginning of nap time. So if she is not asleep by 2 and she hasn't hollered "Mommy, I need to go poopy" I can pretty much count on the fact that she went in her pants or lately pull-ups.
Let me be very clear in telling you that she knows EXACTLY what she is doing. Let me share with you how I have no doubt in my mind about that. Sunday afternoon through Tuesday afternoon she chose to play in her room during nap time instead of sleeping...thus the pictures below from Wednesday. The first two days I tried everything I could to get her to sleep. Finally on Wednesday I laid out very clearly what would happen if she slept and what would happen if she didn't sleep. I gave her one warning and then left her alone. I thought she was almost asleep but then the I guess she decided to start playing.

Just to let you know how much fun she had, her room was completely straight prior to nap time.
At about 4:15 she came sneaking out. I asked her if she pooped in her pants. She said yes. I checked, but there was no poop. Hmmm....this cannot be good! I looked again and saw some small brown stripes. I asked her where the poop was. "In my trashcan"......inside my head I am screaming "in your what?"...then I'm pretty sure I started screaming in my head in some foreign language unrecognizable even to my own brain. I am terrified to go in her room, but I do. I see the picture from above, plus I see the one below....

Yes, that is poop on her dresser. There was also a place on her bedspread and her dress upon further examination. So here's what went down...at least what I gathered from my expert detective skills. She pooped in her pull-up. She took her tights off (she had a dress on), pulled her stool over to her dresser (pull ups are in top drawer), put on a new pair. In the process of changing her own pants she got poop on her dress, bedspread, and dresser. Now tell me that she doesn't know exactly what she is doing.
The only time in the past 2 1/2 weeks this has not happened was the 3 days we were in Eldorado over Easter weekend. She pooped in the toilet all 3 days.
Now let me share with you what we have tried. I have tried positive reinforcement, negative consequences, and ignoring it...not reacting at all except to change the pants. I have bribed with everything I can think of. There has been no TV or movies, no playdates. I even went as far as to go to the park for a playdate and made her sit in the stroller for almost an hour and watch the other kids play. One day we were going to go to McDonalds (Nate was working that night) to eat and play if she pooped in the potty. I drove us to McDonalds, got myself something to eat, went back home, and then ate it in front of her while fixing her something else. That made her mad but not mad enough to go in the toilet the next day. Yes, I have spanked until I am afraid to spank her anymore because I am so mad at her. Nothing seems to bother her. I honestly have absolutely no idea what to do.
We went to a friend's house today. I wasn't going to because of this poop regression, but I had to get out of the house. She came in from outside to go potty halfway through (we don't have a problem with the peeing). We were getting ready to leave when I discovered she had pooped in her pants. Yes, I made her ride home in it. I put her in the tub when we got home and then to bed for her nap. Thank the Lord she is asleep in her room right now.
I am looking for ideas, suggestions, anything that you think might possibly work. Yes, she has a new sibling. Nolan is 4 1/2 months old. It could be related to that. What I don't get (if it is) is that I have been spending more time with her lately then in the past 6 months. Nolan is not as needy and takes great naps. Every morning during his nap time I try to spend doing things specifically with her. I am just baffled and at a total loss. This has to stop, but I don't know what to do. I don't even know how to handle today's incident when she wakes up. I can handle drastic ideas...I am ready to try anything that is not illegal! Maybe you may not have ideas, but please ask around with others you know...maybe together some of you may have the idea we need. Until then, please pray for us and my sanity! I don't know why we are having a poop regression and obviously I cannot figure out the solution.
So there...that's my dirty laundry hanging for all to see...literally dirty.
Thanks for any ideas you may have....I need them!